Competence evidence checklist and completed example
Start with one task and one person. This working pack connects the requirement to assessment and a decision, and can be copied into your own register. It is an author-proposed method. Establish your audit scope and applicable ISO 9001 edition from your own requirements. Keep references to public APG guidance in their stated 2015 edition context. The full explanation and sources remain below.
Check these items before sharing the pack
- Scope: person or identifier, role, specific task, covered shifts and substitutes, and the standard edition agreed for the audit.
- Source: requirement identifier and current instruction release; the owner confirms that both apply to this work.
- Criterion: the required performance, acceptable result and critical errors that prevent independent work. Record these before assessment.
- Basis: relevant experience, qualifications or development action suited to the gap. For training, identify the material, release and completion date.
- Assessment: knowledge and practical observation recorded separately, with the date, assessor and evidence reference.
- Decision: permitted scope of independent work, restriction or further action, accepted by an accountable authorised person.
- History: preserve an unsuccessful attempt alongside its repeat. Set a date or change event for the next review.
- Retrieval: another person can trace task to worker and worker to evidence. Share only the data needed for that sample.
Completed example: measuring a part under instruction INS-POM-04
All identifiers, dates and results are fictional. Person P-017 will measure parts on line A. Before assessment, the task owner sets a knowledge threshold of 8/10 and a practical criterion covering instrument selection, datum selection, unit recording and escalation outside tolerance. Every critical step must be correct without prompting. These thresholds belong to the example and are not ISO requirements.
| Task | Criterion | Material and version | Assessment result | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part measurement, line A; P-017; attempt on 5 October 2026 | Knowledge ≥8/10; every critical practical step correct without prompting | INS-POM-04 v3; learning module SZ-POM-03 v2; observation OBS-017-A | Knowledge 8/10; observation: wrong datum selected, practical criterion not met | Assessor J-02: supervised work only; targeted instruction and a fresh observation by 8 October. Retain the unsuccessful attempt. |
| Repeat observation of the same task; 8 October 2026 | Same criterion, including correct escalation of a simulated out-of-tolerance result | INS-POM-04 v3; OBS-017-B; instruction record dated 6 October | Every critical step correct without prompting; exception escalated correctly | J-02 approves independent measurement within the assessed scope; review after an instruction or task change, or an identified gap. |
| Follow-up on the development action; 22 October 2026 | 10 subsequent records from the covered task: correct method, unit and disposition | INS-POM-04 v3; sample PRZ-017-10; OBS-017-B | 10/10 records meet the agreed criterion; sample covers line A on the regular shift | J-02 maintains the decision within that scope. The sample does not cover another line or a new measurement method. |
The first attempt meets the knowledge threshold while practical observation reveals a gap. Keep both results. Independent work in this example is accepted only after reassessment. The later record review evaluates the development action within its defined scope; it does not establish unlimited validity.
The blank CSV and completed CSV use identical fields. Replace the scenario with your own task, identify the source of the criterion and choose an authorised assessor. The template does not issue an authorisation or determine an audit outcome. Keep evidence in the approved location and record its identifiers instead of copying unnecessary personal data.
Downloads without registration
Start with the edition your audit actually covers
ISO 9001:2026 was published on 16 September 2026. ISO's official catalogue identifies the new edition and marks the 2015 edition as withdrawn [3].
This is a change in the published standard, not evidence that every certificate issued against the earlier edition became invalid that day. Confirm the applicable audit criteria and transition arrangements with your certification body before preparing the evidence package.
Use guidance within its stated scope
This distinction matters for competence records. Public guidance from the ISO and IAF Auditing Practices Group discusses competence under ISO 9001:2015, including that edition's clause 7.2 [1]. It remains useful background for understanding the difference between attending training and demonstrating competence. It should not be presented as the licensed text or a complete interpretation of the 2026 edition. Use the applicable standard for exact requirements.
The practical approach below is a proposed evidence method. It connects requirements, people, development actions and assessment decisions without prescribing one software product or one certificate template. ISO's public guidance on documented information for the 2015 edition recognises different media and the need for documentation suited to the organisation [2]. A convincing evidence set explains what happened and why the result was accepted.
Explain why the competence is needed
Begin with the work, rather than the course register. Identify the task or process that requires competence and its relationship to product or service quality. A person checking a measurement, releasing material or adjusting process settings can affect conformity in a different way from someone maintaining an administrative register. Their evidence should reflect those differences. Define the relevant requirement in terms that can be assessed. An illustrative inspection requirement might be: select the applicable sampling plan, use the specified instrument, interpret the acceptance limit and escalate a result outside the limit. A statement such as "knows inspection" is too broad to explain how competence was recognised.
Show the source of the requirement and its owner. This can be a controlled instruction, process description, customer requirement or documented role decision. The owner should decide the criterion and assess whether the evidence remains relevant after work changes. A training coordinator can administer the action without becoming responsible for technical acceptance. Clear ownership lets the technical leader concentrate on assessing the work and explaining the next development step. Check scope at person level. Experienced staff can take on new duties that their historical evidence does not cover. Conversely, a person moving away from a task may no longer need its current training assignment. Retain the historical record while updating the current requirement. This avoids treating the course catalogue as a permanent list of obligations for every employee.
Recognise relevant existing evidence
Training is not the only route to competence. Education, experience, qualifications and demonstrated work can provide relevant evidence, depending on the task and the applicable requirements. The APG guidance encourages assessment suited to the context rather than assuming that course attendance alone establishes competence [1]. The organisation still needs a reasoned acceptance decision. Review an external certificate for scope, authenticity and relevance. Its title may sound appropriate while the assessed activity differs from the employee's actual work. A general quality course does not demonstrate competence with a specific measuring method. An experienced person may need only a targeted check, while a new task can require supervised development.
Record the basis for recognising existing competence. Identify what was reviewed, who reviewed it and which task or requirement the decision covers. Avoid recreating a fictional training event simply because the system accepts courses more easily than other evidence. The record should describe what actually supported the decision. If the available evidence is insufficient, state the gap clearly. The response might be instruction, mentoring, practice, a discussion, a formal course or an assessment. Choose an action that addresses the missing capability. Sending everyone on the same generic course is easier to schedule, but may leave the original task gap unchanged.
Match assessment to the required capability
A knowledge test can examine decisions, limits and escalation rules. It is less suitable for demonstrating a physical setup, an inspection technique or reliable performance in an abnormal condition. For those tasks, use evidence that includes the activity itself or an appropriate simulation. Keep knowledge and practical assessment results distinct. Define the acceptance criterion before assessing people. Identify the critical steps, allowable assistance and conditions under which the result is valid. If a worker performs a setup with continuous prompting, that can be a useful development stage. It does not necessarily demonstrate independent performance. The assessor should record the distinction.
Use the source instruction to design the assessment. In an illustrative manufacturing scenario, a revised inspection method changes the response to an inconsistent reading. Assess the person's interpretation of that condition, not merely their ability to name the instrument. Add the response to an unusable instrument or unclear acceptance limit where that decision is important to the task. Retain the result and the accountable decision. An assessor's name, date, task scope and conclusion provide more context than an unexplained approved flag. Where a formal authorisation is required, maintain its decision separately. A course completion certificate should not silently become permission to perform restricted work.
Evaluate whether the development action worked
Development activity and effectiveness are connected but different. The organisation can deliver a course as planned and still leave a person unable to perform the intended task. The APG competence guidance explicitly distinguishes training participation from evidence that a person is competent [1]. Define how the action's intended outcome will be checked. For a narrow knowledge gap, a focused discussion or scenario test may be sufficient. For a practical gap, observe work under suitable conditions. For a broader process issue, review relevant outcomes while recognising other influences such as equipment, materials and workload. A reduction in errors can support an evaluation, but does not automatically prove that training caused it.
Set a follow-up point that makes sense for the work. If the task occurs infrequently, an immediate generic questionnaire will not establish sustained performance. An assessment at the next representative task may be more useful, giving the assessor a chance to discuss the actual difficulty with the employee while it is visible. Record any supervision or restriction applied while the evidence is incomplete. When the criterion is not met, document the response. Additional explanation, practice, revised material or a process correction can be appropriate. Do not erase the unsuccessful result after a successful repeat. The sequence shows that a gap was detected and managed, which is more informative than a register that appears to contain only first-time success.
Make the evidence trace work in both directions
An audit sample may start with a person. The organisation should then be able to show that person's applicable duties, requirements, evidence and current status. Another sample may start with a critical task or a revised instruction. It should lead to the affected population and explain whether their requirements were fulfilled before relevant work. Use stable identifiers for people, requirements and document releases. Names alone can be ambiguous, while a course title can recur across several revisions. The evidence should identify the source and assessment that actually applied to the event. Do not relabel historical completions with the newest procedure version.
Assemble a concise package around the selected sample. Include the requirement, acceptance criterion, evidence, assessment decision and unresolved actions. A report containing every training event in the organisation creates volume without necessarily answering the question. Keep references to supporting records so the reviewer can inspect the detail when needed. Explain exclusions. An employee may have been absent, transferred, supervised or outside the task scope. Those conditions affect interpretation. A report generation time and visible filters distinguish a historical snapshot from today's current position. The package should allow a reviewer to understand the record without relying on the training coordinator's memory or repeatedly interrupting team leaders to reconstruct an assessment.
Check changes, exceptions and the working environment
Competence evidence needs review when the work changes. A new machine, altered instruction, changed product, incident or long break from a task may reduce the relevance of earlier evidence. The requirement owner should assess impact. Not every editorial correction demands full retraining, but a material change should not wait for an arbitrary annual anniversary. Inspect exceptions before an audit. Look for overdue assessments, changed duties without updated requirements, missing source versions and practical approvals recorded only in a manager's mailbox. An exception is not closed because someone adds a comment saying it will be resolved. Identify an owner, action and expected evidence.
Also consider whether the process enables competent work. If operators receive conflicting instructions or cannot access the correct instrument, another training assignment may fail to address the cause. Evidence of competence does not remove the organisation's responsibility to provide suitable conditions and controlled instructions. Do not prepare an artificially clean story for the audit. Preserve the actual sequence and explain improvements. A credible record can contain a detected gap, a temporary control and a completed corrective action. A report that silently overwrites the gap may be harder to defend because it no longer reflects the decisions made at the time.
Prepare through a sample, not a last-minute document hunt
Select one task with meaningful quality consequences and one recent change. Ask someone unfamiliar with the records to reconstruct the competence decision. Can they find the requirement, source release, relevant people, evidence and responsible assessor? Where the trace breaks, repair the record or the process that creates it.
Keep the distinction between evidence preparation and certification. CrewShift can support procedure assignments, scores, completion history and exports. These can form part of an evidence package. Create an account and test one assessment trace with the responsible leader: can they retrieve the learning records and spend the review discussing the remaining development need? The organisation determines the competence criteria, makes practical or authorisation decisions and confirms the applicable audit requirements. A software record does not award ISO certification or guarantee an audit outcome.
Prepare for the edition transition
For the 2026 transition, review the licensed standard and agreed certification plan before rewriting internal requirements. Do not copy old clause numbers into new procedures simply because an older guidance document uses them. Preserve useful historical records and map them to the requirements that actually apply.
The most useful preparation is a clear answer to a specific question: why did the organisation consider this person competent for this task under these conditions? A course certificate may be part of that answer. The requirement, assessment and accountable decision make the answer assessable. Keeping that reasoning available also helps a leader choose the next useful practice or mentoring activity with the employee.
Questions worth asking
Is a certificate mandatory?
The required record depends on the requirement. A reliable link between person, scope, date, result and source version matters more than certificate appearance.
Does a test always prove competence?
No. A test checks knowledge within a defined scope. Practical tasks may also require observed performance or formal authorization.
Is ISO 9001:2015 still the newest published edition?
No. ISO published ISO 9001:2026 on 16 September 2026. Confirm the applicable audit criteria and transition arrangements with the certification body; publication does not itself establish immediate invalidity of existing certificates.
Can public APG guidance replace the current licensed standard?
No. The cited competence guidance discusses the 2015 edition. It supports understanding but is not the licensed text or a complete interpretation of the 2026 edition.
Sources and scope
- ISO / IAF Auditing Practices Group — guidance on auditing competence (2015 edition context)
- ISO / TC176 — guidance on documented information (ISO 9001:2015)
- ISO 9001:2026 — official edition and publication status
This informational material does not replace licensed standards or individual legal advice.

